Site vs. Situation:  Location!  Location!  Location! 
 
Angelia Mance  
University of North Alabama   

Overview of Lesson Materials
Connection to the Curriculum,Standards and Skills  Body of Lesson - Procedure & Assessment
Grade Level Activity One and Student Assessment
Purpose of Lesson Activity Two and Student Assessment
Primary Geographic Question Assessment of Lesson
Secondary Questions References

Overview of the Lesson

You’ve heard the phrase, “Location matters.”  This lesson illustrates why this is so.  An examination of places that have a similar latitude to Alabama will reveal the importance of a location’s site versus its situation.  Upon completion of the lesson, the importance of taking into account the totality of a location’s geography should be clear.
Connection to the Curriculum, Standards, and Skills
Geography Standards
Standard 1:  How to use maps and other geographic representations,    tools, and technologies to acquire, process, and report information from a spatial perspective.

Standard 4:  The physical and human characteristics of places.

Standard 9:  The characteristics, distribution, and migration of human populations on Earth’s surface.

Standard 15:  How physical systems affect human systems..

Alabama Course of Study:  Social Studies Content Standards (Grade 7)
Standard 1:  Explain map essentials: type, size, shape, distance, direction, location, scale, symbols.

Standard 5:  Locate selected countries, cities, and physical features on maps, globes, and satellite images.

Standard 8:  Compare the physical and human characteristics of places using observation data and geographic resources.

Standard 11:  Explain patterns in the physical environment within the context of physical processes.

Standard 13:  Describe ecosystems and why they differ from place to place.

Standard 17:  Relate economic activity of a region within its geographic context.

Standard 19:  Discuss major industries in the United States from the perspective of how geography and the factors of production helped determine the location of manufacturing plants.

Standard 20:  Identify major agricultural and urban settlement types and the geographic reasons for their location.

Geographic Skills
Acquiring geographic information: analyze maps, charts, and graphs to determine patterns: identify major settlement types and the geographic reasons for their location: explain how the characteristics of different physical environments affect human activities; understand interaction between humans and the physical environment.
Grade Level
Grade 7
Purpose of the Lesson
To analyze maps to find places of similar latitude to Alabama, and to determine whether or not they share similar physical and human characteristics.
Primary Geographic Question Secondary Questions Materials
Body of Lesson - Procedure & Assessment
Activity One
Explain to the students that site is defined as the specific place where something is located  including its physical setting, while situation is defined as the general location of something in relation to other places or larger features.

Ask the students to start with the latitudinal area of a place such as Florence, Alabama ( 34.46o N).  Suggest that a globe is utilized first to see what areas appear to be of similar latitude then use the atlas for specific locations. Some suggestions:  Abu Kamal, Syria, 34.45o N; Akashi, Japan, 34.38o N; Gavdhos Island, Greece, 34.48o N.

Divide students into small groups, assigning each group one area of similar latitude.  Using chart paper, have each group list pre-determined characteristics of each location chosen.  Consider using industry, agriculture, population density, settlement patterns, etc.

When each group has completed their portion of the assignment, have the groups come together to determine whether areas of similar latitude share other characteristics.

Assessing Student Learning: Activity One
Have each group display their chart.  They should be able to explain how they obtained and interpreted their data, as well as how they selected their location to study.
Activity Two
Assessing Student Learning: Activity Two
Students should be able to enumerate the differences they find, and hypothesize about why these differences exist.
Assessment of Lesson
Students should now be able to articulate the difference between site and situation, and be able to determine spatial patterns from the data they collected and compared about areas of similar latitude.  Ask students to write a paragraph in response to the primary question.
References
 Goode’s World Atlas (Rand McNally)
 
  
Top of Page
Back to Lessons Page
Back to Home Page
 



Created by Lisa Keys-Mathews.  8/12/98.  Last revision 9/30/98.  lkm